Life after Cheshire West – valid consent and the new law of deprivation of liberty – [2026] Fam Law 1049
![Life after Cheshire West – valid consent and the new law of deprivation of liberty – [2026] Fam Law 1049](https://www.parklaneplowden.co.uk/app/uploads/2024/10/Avaia-Williams-Banner.png)
We are pleased to share that Court of Protection barrister, Avaia Williams, has been published in the October 2026 edition of Family Law Journal.
In his latest article, Avaia examines the Supreme Court’s decision in AGNI [2026] UKSC 16 and its implications for deprivation of liberty practice following the overruling of Cheshire West. Looking beyond the headline outcome, he explores the Strasbourg authorities underpinning the judgment and the distinction between mental capacity under domestic law and valid consent for the purposes of Article 5.
Avaia considers the practical challenges of the new multifactorial assessment, including the significance of purpose, relative normality, and the individual’s wishes and feelings. He examines the difficulties of distinguishing genuine consent from acquiescence, and the risks of relying on apparent happiness or acceptance without sufficiently investigating the person’s circumstances.
The article also considers the wider consequences for disability rights, legal aid and access to justice. Where care arrangements fall outside Article 5, Avaia questions how individuals will obtain effective scrutiny of restrictive arrangements and explores the increasing importance of public law duties and alternative routes of challenge.
Reflecting on the safeguards developed since Cheshire West, Avaia concludes:
“Perhaps the greatest legacy of Cheshire West was not simply the acid test, but the procedural ecosystem and oversight that developed around it. AGNI has fundamentally altered the scope of that ecosystem. Whether the safeguards which remain outside Art 5 prove sufficient to protect some of society’s most vulnerable individuals is a question which neither the Supreme Court nor Strasbourg was required to answer, but one which practitioners, policymakers and, inevitably, the appellate courts will increasingly be called upon to confront.” Avaia’s piece can be accessed here for those with a subscription to LexisNexis or in the October copy of Family Law Journal.










